Response to Six4Three Documents

Social Media

Technology / Social Media 117 Views comments

As we’ve stated many occasions, Six4Three — creators of the Pikinis app — cherrypicked these paperwork from years in the past as a part of a lawsuit to pressure Fb to share info on associates of the app’s customers. The set of paperwork, by design, tells just one aspect of the story and omits necessary context.

We nonetheless stand by the platform modifications we made in 2014/2015, which prevented individuals from sharing their buddies’ info with builders just like the creators of Pikinis. The extensions we granted at the moment have been brief time period and solely used to stop individuals from dropping entry to particular features as builders up to date their apps. Pikinis didn’t obtain an extension, they usually went to courtroom.

The paperwork have been selectively leaked to publish some, however not all, of the interior discussions at Fb on the time of our platform modifications. However the details are clear: we’ve by no means bought individuals’s knowledge.

Sadly, choose quotes from these paperwork have been launched to recommend issues which are false. For instance, accusations about potential misuse of our APIs have been made in a current listening to earlier than the DCMS Choose Committee, however the full story was omitted. We finally launched the emails displaying that engineers who initially raised questions on “billions” of API calls realized there have been solely about 6 million reputable calls from Pinterest, not a Russian actor.

Responses to Particular Areas

White Lists

There is a vital distinction between pals’ knowledge and good friend lists.

We modified our platform insurance policies in 2014/15 to stop apps from requesting permission to entry pals’ info. The historical past of Cambridge Analytica exhibits this was the correct factor to do. For many builders, we additionally restricted their potential to request an inventory of who somebody’s associates have been, until these buddies have been additionally utilizing the developer’s app. In some conditions, when needed, we allowed builders to entry an inventory of the customers’ associates. This was not associates’ personal info however an inventory of your folks (identify and profile pic). (Up to date on December 5, 2018 at 2:15PM PT to make clear the character of the knowledge that might be requested.)

As well as, white lists are additionally widespread follow when testing new options and performance with a restricted set of companions earlier than rolling out the function extra broadly (aka beta testing). Equally, it’s widespread to assist companions transition their apps throughout platform modifications to stop their apps from crashing or inflicting disruptive experiences for customers.

Worth of Pals’ Knowledge

The developer platform is free for builders to make use of.

We explored a number of methods to construct a sustainable enterprise with builders who have been constructing apps that have been helpful to individuals. However as an alternative of requiring builders to purchase promoting – the choice mentioned in these cherrypicked emails – we finally settled on a mannequin the place builders didn't have to buy promoting to entry APIs and we continued to offer the developer platform free of charge.


In 2013, Fb had the next “reciprocity” provision in its Fb Platform Insurance policies:

“Reciprocity: Fb Platform allows builders to construct personalised, social experiences by way of the Graph API and associated APIs. For those who use any Fb APIs to construct personalised or social experiences, you should additionally allow individuals to simply share their experiences again with individuals on Fb.”

This coverage required builders to offer individuals the choice to share info again to Fb by way of the developer’s app. This meant that you may share your app expertise (recreation rating, photograph, and so forth.) again to your Fb pals for those who needed to. Individuals had the selection about whether or not they did this or not.

Name and SMS Historical past on Android

This particular function permits individuals to choose in to giving Fb entry to their name and textual content messaging logs in Fb Lite and Messenger on Android units. We use this info to do issues like make higher ideas for individuals to name in Messenger and rank contact lists in Messenger and Fb Lite. After a radical assessment in 2018, it turned clear that the knowledge shouldn't be as helpful after a few yr. For instance, as we use this info to record contacts which might be most helpful to you, previous name historical past is much less helpful. You're unlikely to wish to name somebody who you final referred to as over a yr in the past in comparison with a contact you referred to as simply final week.

[Updated on December 5, 2018 at 1:20PM PST after receiving additional questions from press about some emails that discuss possible permission updates for Call and SMS history on Android. The below paragraph provides further clarification.]

The function is choose in for customers and we ask for individuals’s permission earlier than enabling. We all the time contemplate one of the simplest ways to ask for an individual’s permission, whether or not that’s by way of a permission dialog set by a cellular working system like Android or iOS, or a permission we design within the Fb app. With this function, we requested for permission contained in the Fb Messenger app, and this was a dialogue about how our determination to launch this opt-in function would work together with the Android working system’s personal permission screens. This was not a dialogue about avoiding asking individuals for permission.


Onavo supplies individuals with a free VPN app that creates a safer connection when you’re utilizing apps or accessing the online in your telephone. As a part of offering the service, Onavo collects details about app utilization to realize insights into the services individuals worth, so we will construct higher experiences. We’ve all the time been clear when individuals obtain Onavo concerning the info that's collected and the way it's used, together with by Fb. We let individuals know earlier than they obtain the app and on the primary display they see after putting in it. Additionally, individuals can opt-out by way of the management of their settings and their knowledge gained’t be used for something aside from to offer, enhance and develop Onavo services. Web sites and apps have used instruments like Onavo for market analysis providers for years. We use Onavo, App Annie, comScore, and publicly out there instruments to assist us perceive the market and enhance all our providers.

Concentrating on Competitor Apps

We constructed our developer platform years in the past to pave the best way for innovation in social apps and providers. At the moment we made the choice to limit apps constructed on prime of our platform that replicated our core performance. These sort of restrictions are widespread throughout the tech business with totally different platforms having their very own variant together with YouTube, Twitter, Snap and Apple. We recurrently evaluation our insurance policies to make sure they're each defending individuals’s knowledge and enabling helpful providers to be constructed on our platform for the good thing about the Fb group. As a part of our ongoing evaluate we have now determined that we'll take away this out-of-date coverage in order that our platform stays as open as attainable. We expect that is the suitable factor to do as platforms and know-how develop and develop.